I have never bought that Neapolitan mastiffs represented a relic population of Roman Molossus dogs. I do agree that mastiff type dogs are pretty old, but making claims about dogs based upon whether they superficially resemble dogs that appear on old artifacts is a very dubious proposition. (My personal favorite claim is that the Ancient Egyptians had dachshunds because one can find short-legged dogs depicted in wall art from that time period.)
So what was a Neapolitan mastiff before it became a fancy show dog?
Well, the old name for this breed in Engliahs was “Italian bulldog,” a name that I initially thought was dubious. These dogs do superficially look like bulldogs, but they are much more like mastiffs than bulldogs.
It turns out that the name “Italian bulldog” wasn’t a dubious proposition. These mastiffs were used as farm dogs- most specifically as livestock guardians that watched over herds of cattle.
My source for this bit of information comes from the 1908 Diplomatic and Consular Reports from the British Foreign Office:
The Neapolitan mastiff is a heavy and useful cattle dog. He has a fine smooth coat and is generally brindled or black. He is kind by nature, but easily made savage if he is tied up or ill-treated. His original use was to go out with the cattle and goats and protect them from the wolves which in olden days were very common all over the district. Then, as now, he guarded the homestead at night (pg. 15).
The dog wasn’t a bulldog in the same way that the English used them, but it isn’t that different from the way the Southern farm bulldogs were used in the United States. Farm bulldogs were (and still are) used to guard stock and children to protect them from predators of all types.
So the Neapolitan mastiff’s original function wasn’t as a Roman war dog or a fighter in the Colosseum.
It was a type of livestock guardian dog– the indigenous livestock guardian dog of southern Italy.
It’s a lot less romantic original function than the one that connects this dog to the Roman Empire.
But it’s not unexpected.
Italians are not Romans. Italy has had a history since the fall of Rome.
And Italy itself didn’t exist as unified nation until the late nineteenth century.
The southern part of what is now Italy has been under the control of so many different political entities and royal houses that all sorts of different influences have come into the region.
A Neapolitan mastiff never existed as a closed registry breed until after the Second World War. The farm dogs of southern Italy were constantly getting new blood from different regions. There was a selection for strong guardian instincts but also docility toward the family and stock.
This also goes a long way to explaining why many early imports of Neapolitan mastiff to the United States often bonded very strongly to their owners and hated everyone else. This is exactly what one would want in a livestock guardian dog. Although North America livestock guardian dogs have been selected for a more docile temperament, those from the Old World often had tendencies toward hyper bonding toward stock and family and high aggression toward outsiders.
It also suggests that the traditional spiked collar that these dogs wear has more to do with protecting the neck from attacks from wolves than anything else. The same goes for the cropped ears. Many livestock guardian breeds have cropped ears and wear spiked collars to assist in fending off attacks from wolves. Spiked collars prevent the wolves from biting down on the neck, and the nearly amputated ears don’t provide anything for the wolves to grab.
I’ve not seen anyone recommending Neapolitan mastiffs for this purpose. The fancy show dog is probably not hardy enough to withstand rustic conditions, though the dogs might be useful on a small farm where they can be observed more closely.
***
In my research on Lord Byron’s Newfoundland, I came across another dog he owned.
In 1819, Byron procured a “bulldog” from Italy. This dog was named Moretto.
This particular dog accompanied Bryon on his ill-fated decision to join the Greeks in their war of independence against the Ottomans,
And I don’t know if anyone has considered this possibility, but it may have been that Moretto actually was part of the landrace that gave us the Neapolitan mastiff.
I’ve seen that the Newfoundland people have taken the story of Boatswain and run with it almost as far it could go. Never mind that Boatswain wasn’t anything like the dogs we call Newfoundlands today.
But if Newfoundland dog people can make hay with Boatswain, I don’t see why the Neapolitan mastiff people aren’t making hay with Moretto.
Moretto was probably very much like the rough Neapolitan mastiffs before they became show dogs. Perhaps, he was much more like them than Boatswain was like today’s shaggy giant Newfoundland.
But people are selective in what romantic stories they want to believe.
The fact that Moretto was always described as a bulldog may have thrown everyone off.
Of course, the Neapolitan mastiff was always called the Italian bulldog in English until very recently.
I can’t imagine there ever being true English bulldog types in Italy until the foundation of the modern dog fancy, so it seems to me much more likely that he was a Neapolitan mastiff.


















